SEO Proposal Review
An independent verdict on your SEO proposal.
Upload the proposal. We’ll score it, stress-test the commercials, and tell you plainly whether it’s worth moving forward.
✓ No obligation ✓ Scope confirmed before payment ✓ Independent advice
The Problem
Most SEO proposals are written to be signed, not understood.
Jargon-heavy strategy decks, vague deliverables, and pricing that’s hard to benchmark. Most business owners have no reliable way to tell a strong SEO proposal from a weak one until months in.
You’ve been sent a proposal.
It sounds credible.
You have no way to check.
Submit Your Proposal
No payment required yet. We’ll review your submission, confirm the scope, and send a secure payment link before any work begins.
What’s Included
Everything in your Decision Pack.
✓ Review of up to 2 proposals
✓ Executive Verdict
✓ BYI Confidence Score™
✓ Commercial risk assessment
✓ Missing deliverables analysis
✓ Agency comparison
✓ Questions to ask before signing
✓ Professional PDF Decision Pack
✓ Delivered within 5 working days
✓ Optional 30-minute follow-up call
Pricing
One clear price. No hidden extras.
SEO PROPOSAL REVIEW
£195
- ✓ Review of up to 2 proposals
- ✓ Executive Verdict
- ✓ BYI Confidence Score™
- ✓ Commercial risk assessment
- ✓ Missing deliverables analysis
- ✓ Agency comparison
- ✓ Questions to ask before signing
- ✓ Professional PDF Decision Pack
- ✓ Delivered within 5 working days
- ✓ Optional 30-minute follow-up call
Submit proposals → Scope confirmed → Payment link sent → Review begins
Who It’s For
Built for anyone about to sign, not already regretting it.
Founders & Business Owners
About to commit real budget to an SEO agency, and want a second, independent opinion before signing.
Marketing Decision-Makers
Comparing two or three agency proposals and need an objective way to tell them apart.
In-House Teams
Reviewing a renewal or a new statement of work, and want an outside check before recommending it upward.
BYI Confidence Score™
One score. Six pillars. Complete clarity.
Every proposal we review is scored independently across six pillars, so you can see exactly where it’s strong, and where it isn’t.
Transparency
Are pricing, deliverables, and reporting spelled out clearly, with nothing left to interpretation?
Communication
Plain English, or jargon designed to sound more impressive than it is?
Strategy
Is the proposed approach specific to your business, or a generic template dressed up as a plan?
Technical Approach
Is there evidence of a real technical audit, or just assumptions about your site?
Commercial
Do the numbers stack up? Is the cost proportionate to the scope and likely return?
Value for Money
Would a reasonable business owner feel this price matches what’s being delivered?
Understanding Your Score
What each verdict means.
Proceed
The proposal holds up. Sign with confidence.
Proceed with Conditions
Sound overall, but a few points are worth renegotiating first.
Caution
Real gaps exist. Address them before committing budget.
Do Not Proceed
We wouldn’t recommend signing this as it stands.
See It For Yourself
Not sure yet? See a full example Decision Pack first.
Download a real, anonymised example of what you’ll receive — same structure, same scoring, same level of detail.
How It Works
From proposal to Decision Pack, step by step.
01
Submit your proposal(s)
Upload one or two SEO proposals securely through the form.
02
Get a confirmation email
We confirm we’ve received everything and outline next steps.
03
Scope confirmed
Within one working day, we confirm exactly what the review covers.
04
Secure payment link
Once scope is confirmed, we send a secure Stripe payment link.
05
Review begins
Our independent review starts as soon as payment is received.
06
Decision Pack delivered
Delivered within 5 working days, plus an optional follow-up call.
Why Before You Invest
Human-led decision making with real experience.
Independent
We don’t sell SEO services. Nothing we say is shaped by what we’d like to sell you next.
Evidence-led
Every point in your Decision Pack is backed by something we can point to, not a gut feeling.
Commercial
We care whether you’ll actually get value for the money, not just whether the strategy sounds good.
Plain English
No jargon, no acronyms you have to look up. If we can’t explain it simply, we don’t include it.
Honest
Sometimes the right advice is: don’t sign this proposal, or don’t hire anyone at all.
FAQ
Questions before you submit.
No. You submit your proposal(s) first. We confirm the scope and send a secure payment link only after we’ve reviewed what you’ve sent, so you’ll know exactly what’s covered before you pay anything.
Yes. Your proposal is used only to produce your Decision Pack and is not shared with any third party, including the agency who sent it.
That’s fine. The £395 review covers up to two proposals, but works just as well for a single one.
Once payment is confirmed, your Decision Pack is delivered within 5 working days.
Yes. An optional 30-minute follow-up call is included, so you can talk through the verdict before deciding anything.
Ready to know if that proposal is actually worth signing?
No payment required yet. We’ll review your submission, confirm the scope, and send a secure payment link before any work begins.